Why your Product Discovery Feels too Theoretical


Why your Product Discovery
Feels too Theoretical

READ ON

HERBIG.CO

PUBLISHED

Apr 25, 2025

READING TIME

4 min & 17 sec

​Dear Reader,​

Over the past two weeks, I've explored treating Product Strategy and OKRs like products to avoid Alibi Progress. Today, let's tackle the practice that often gets dismissed as "good in theory, impossible in practice" — Product Discovery.

When teams tell me "we don't have time for proper Discovery," they're usually stuck in Alibi Progress — focusing on following lengthy processes rather than reducing uncertainties from wherever they are right now. Discovery doesn't need a 28-phase framework to be valuable.

Let's treat Discovery like a product to make it practical:

For product teams, Product Discovery helps reduce uncertainty about problems and solutions worth pursuing. We know it's valuable when investment decisions are based on reliable evidence rather than assumptions, and teams avoid building features that don't solve validated problems.

Let's unpack this value statement:

For your audience (product teams with high uncertainty)

  • Discovery isn't equally valuable for all teams at all times—its intensity should match your level of uncertainty.
  • Teams with established products in mature markets might need less extensive discovery than those entering new spaces.
  • If stakeholders become the primary audience, Discovery risks becoming a theater of validation rather than genuine learning.

For the problem you're solving (reducing risk through evidence):

For your success measures (evidence-based decisions):

  • Track how many feature ideas were discarded based on Discovery evidence (a healthy Discovery process kills bad ideas).
  • Monitor the adoption of shipped features that went through Discovery versus those that didn't. Putting an Epic into the Done column doesn't mean it had an Impact on customer behavior or business goals.
  • Evaluate how quickly teams reach sufficient confidence to make decisions, not just how many research activities they completed.

Instead of worrying about following discovery theory, I recommend a practical approach: the "one-week test." If you could spend one week reducing uncertainty about your biggest uncertainty, what would you do? This approach forces teams to focus on high-leverage activities rather than comprehensive processes.

Remember: You're not a better product manager because you followed a six-phase Discovery process exactly. You're better when you can confidently explain, based on reliable evidence, which customer problems are worth solving.

Did you enjoy the newsletter? Please forward it. It only takes two clicks. Creating this one took two hours.

Thank you for Practicing Product,

Tim

PS: My inner dialogue whenever I discover a new coffee brewer:

How to Dive Deeper into Product Discovery

Learn how I helped companies like Deutsche Telekom and Forto hone their Product Discovery practices. I closely work with product organizations through workshops and coaching to introduce and adapt Product Discovery.

Content I found Practical This Week

Product Discovery with Internal Customers

video preview

We did all this discovery... now how do we decide?

To help us to eliminate (not forever, but for the purpose of making a decision now) I've found one technique very helpful. The trick is to flip things around. Instead of describing the good that will happen by doing an idea, we look at what goes wrong when we don't do it. To make that flip, we can ask two simple questions:

Sample size and confidence: How to get your team to trust qualitative research

The only thing that matters is how confident your team is about the next decision they need to make. You might get that confidence from watching 2 people. You might need to watch 20. You might need to watch 20, then check your hypothesis at a larger scale with a survey or analytics. It all depends on the confidence of your team.

Who is Tim Herbig?

As a Product Management Coach, I guide Product Teams to measure the real progress of their evidence-informed decisions.

I focus on better practices to connect the dots of Product Strategy, Product OKRs, and Product Discovery.

Product Practice Newsletter

1 tip & 3 resources per week to improve your Strategy, OKRs, and Discovery practices in less than 5 minutes.

Read more from Product Practice Newsletter

This is the last newsletter before my annual summer writing break. I will be back in your inbox on August 17. Have a wonderful summer! ☀️ Product Practice #370 My 2025 Mid-Year Review READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Jul 4, 2025 READING TIME 4 min & 06 sec Dear Reader, What I focused on in the first half of 2025 Writing and Editing My Book After a big writing push from February to April, I was able to share the first complete draft of my book Real Progress - How to Connect Product Strategy, OKRs,...

Product Practice #369 Product Discovery Triangulation READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Jun 29, 2025 READING TIME 4 min & 47 sec Dear Reader, To get to an informed conviction through Product Discovery, product teams often need to be creative. It can be challenging for Product Discovery collaborators to make real progress, especially when they lack an environment that provides the right amount of guidance without being too constraining for Adaptable Product Discovery.That’s why today’s newsletter is...

Product Practice #368 How a Product Vision Board saved my Strategy READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Jun 20, 2025 READING TIME 3 min & 53 sec Dear Reader, I once led a newly formed product team that aimed to develop a product to increase the monetization of a specific user segment. I co-led a long Discovery effort that validated and scoped this product. At one point during our Delivery journey, my boss approached the team while I was on leave and asked them what they were trying to accomplish....