In 2025, stop trying to get better at OKRs


In 2025, stop trying
to get better at OKRs

READ ON

HERBIG.CO

PUBLISHED

Jan 31, 2025

READING TIME

4 min & 04 sec

​Dear Reader,​

I hope you had the start of 2025 that you had wished and planned for. I'm excited to get back into the rhythm of weekly publishing, having completed my annual in-person workshop series and gearing up for continued (and new) client engagements. If you're up for it, reply to this newsletter and let me know what one thing you would like to see more (or less) of in this newsletter in 2025.

To get better at OKRs don’t try to get better at OKRs.

Treat OKRs as a product that should solve one problem: measuring progress toward strategic priorities.

OKRs are supposed to be the solution to this problem, which means they shouldn’t…

a) …feature generic evergreen metrics.

b) …include metrics unconnected from what you discover and deliver.

c) …be full of lagging indicators you can only review in hindsight.

Focusing on technical correctness ("Make sure Objectives follow this structure") pushes teams toward OKR Theater.

One practice that seems to have nothing to do with OKRs but has everything to do with OKRs is for teams to own their metrics trees (I’ve written about this structure before here and here).

Consider a checkout team. "Increase Search-to-Buy Conversion Rate by 3%" would be a poor quarterly goal.

Instead, by mapping the drivers of this metric through metrics tree relationships, they can find their influenceable contribution:

They can’t influence what happens in the search or on the product detail page, which moves these branches of the tree outside their sphere of influence. However, they can massively influence the conversion rate from started to completed purchases.

This allows them to turn this branch into their own metrics tree, making “Cart to Purchase Completed Conversion Rate” a healthy reactive KPI to keep track of. But to set proactive goals, they need to make an informed statement about which of these drivers are within their responsibility they want to tackle.

These driver branch breakdowns can work with categories like conversion journey steps, platforms, technical components, etc.

Picking a lever to focus on from these drivers, they could land on an OKR like this:

Objective: Make checkout completion effortless for mobile shoppers

Key Result 1: Reduce mobile form field errors by 40%

Key Result 2: Increase first-attempt address validation success rate to 95%

Key Result 3: Reduce payment method rejection rate by 25%

By treating OKRs as a product and using metrics trees to inform their creation, teams can craft goals that solve their fundamental need: measuring meaningful progress toward strategic priorities. Remember, it's all just metrics, anyway.

Instead of falling into the trap of OKR theater, teams owning their metrics trees can identify and focus on the metrics to…

a) …set goals that represent specific, time-bound bets.

b) …use metrics that they can influence with identified and shipped solutions.

c) …check if their work impacts the goal cycle.

This product-thinking approach to OKRs—starting with the problem they should solve for teams and working backward through metrics relationships—leads to more valuable goals than simply perfecting OKR formatting.

1 Question For You To Put This Into Practice

Look at the influenceable branches of a metrics tree starting from a lagging company metric:
Why aren't these in your OKRs?

Reply and let me know your answer.

Did you enjoy the newsletter? Please forward it. It only takes two clicks. Creating this one took two hours.

Thank you for Practicing Product,

Tim

Good News!

Some last tickets are available for my in-person Product Discovery workshop on March 10 in London (as part of Mind the Product conference).

Content I found Practical This Week

Manage your Life Like You Manage a Product: Explore, Expand, Exploit, Exit—and Reflect

My objective was to model a sustainable, happy life. But that’s more of a life mission. I had to ask myself, what’s a good a three-month objective considering the problem I was solving was making work be good for me again? It was my very first personal objective so it’s a bit overstuffed. Tracking these OKRs weekly helped me evaluate progress and course-correct. By the end of the quarter, I had a clearer picture of what sustainable, fulfilling work looked like and was ready to move forward with confidence.

Goal-O-Rama

Anti-goals (aka NOKRs) explicitly state what you aren't trying to do. They help set expectations and clarify your strategy. A good exercise for setting anti-goals is to ask, "What might someone reasonably assume might happen because of our work that will likely NOT happen?"

Hitting OKRs vs Doing Your Job

When a team’s OKRs duplicate the roadmap, I read that as “We aren’t trying to improve. This is a quarter for trudging along.” Not a good sign. OKRs are for “What is special about this quarter? What is new? How do we want to be different? What do we want to figure out?”

Who is Tim Herbig?

As a Product Management Coach, I guide Product Teams to measure the real progress of their evidence-informed decisions.

I focus on better practices to connect the dots of Product Strategy, Product OKRs, and Product Discovery.

Product Practice Newsletter

1 tip & 3 resources per week to improve your Strategy, OKRs, and Discovery practices in less than 5 minutes.

Read more from Product Practice Newsletter

Product Practice #353 How Duolingo Approaches Strategy, OKRs, and Discovery READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Mar 7, 2025 READING TIME 4 min & 24 sec Dear Reader, Many Product Managers were in awe of the ways of working shared in The Duolingo Handbook a few weeks ago. While it’s an inspiring read, I used this as a reason to revisit some of my all-time favorite reads about how this company operates (or at least used to operate) and extract my takeaways with you. Duolingo focuses on “Movable” Metrics...

Product Practice #352 My Digitale Leute Summit 2024 Keynote Recording and Slides READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Feb 28, 2025 READING TIME 1 min & 40 sec Dear Reader, I'm excited to share the full recording of my talk on How Product Teams Can Connect the Dots of Strategy, OKRs, and Discovery from last year's Digitale Leute Summit. You can think of it as the naturally progressing chapter (hint hint) that would follow my talk from Product at Heart 2024. As always, I won't require you, as an...

Product Practice #351 The Post-it trap: Why Strategy needs more than Workshops READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Feb 21, 2025 READING TIME 5 min & 19 sec Dear Reader, 'Product Strategy by Post-it' occurs when teams prioritize filling out frameworks over making real strategic choices. It's a common symptom of treating strategy as a checkbox exercise rather than a tool for decision-making. John Cutler even suggests that most frameworks should feature a warning label like this: "This framework is...