🛠️ PP #301: How to Pick Useful OKRs from KPI Trees

How to Pick Useful OKRs
from KPI Trees




Nov 10, 2023


4 min & 5 sec

​Dear Reader,​

Frameworks must be in service of the intention product teams try to achieve. One of the most helpful ways to do that is by combining them with the attributes and principles of useful Discovery insights, OKRs, or Strategy components.

As I wrote before, finding valuable metrics for your NSM or OKRs comes down to building your KPI landscape through a KPI tree. Through continuous questions about what a given metric drives or is driven by, you‘ll create your metrics landscape.

But this range of metrics options can be overwhelming, and you shouldn‘t use every metric you could measure. Instead, use practices like the IDLE attributes of useful Product OKRs as a lens to assess the items on your KPI trees to find starting points for your next OKRs.

This could be as simple as a 5-column table. First column: the metric, Other columns: the attributes you look for (like with IDLE). You go through them and check if the attribute is met or not. Where they are met is your starting point for useful KRs.


  • Define what attributes you‘re looking for to make your OKRs useful. What do they have to do for you, so they‘re worth looking at and making decisions based on them?
  • Create a continuously updated and evolving pool of metrics options by getting together with UX, Engineering, Data, Marketing, etc. Domain experts from your product area.
  • Use your previously agreed attributes to select metrics that are ready to use or that are starting points for further discussions.
  • Ensure to avoid the streetlight effect: If a metric is important but not influenceable and detectable, invest in why it isn’t and what you need to do to change it.

That's (almost) all, Reader. If you enjoyed today's issue, please do reply (it helps with deliverability). If you didn't, you can unsubscribe here.

Thank you for Practicing Product,


What did you think of this week's newsletter?







Click here if you only want to see what's behind each option

Content I found Practical This Week

OKRs can be simple

OKRs backfired a little bit, because something that was meant to allow for flexibility and outcome based decision making actually turned into this like really rigid and inflexible system, because everyone would commit to OKRs at the beginning of the quarter, put them into the system, and then couldn’t really budge off of their roadmap for that quarter, because they had committed to these OKRs. And everyone was slightly more focused on whether or not they’d be able to say that they did their OKRs at the end of the quarter, then whether or not we’d actually achieved the outcome. So everyone in product ended up hating it, because there’s a lot of process around it.

Are You Sure You Want to Use OKRs?

If you are spending weeks refining the language of the objective and pinning down just the right metrics, your company is in the business of process management. That’s wasteful. Try to make good OKRs but remember there is a time when you have to say, good enough for now. You don’t want to spend three weeks setting your goals and lose the time you could be working toward them instead. Often people ask me, how do I know what key result to set? How do I know how much it should improve? I say “Go ahead and guess.”

Practical KPI Trees

Who is Tim Herbig?

As a Product Management Coach, I guide Product Teams to measure the progress of their evidence-informed decisions.

I identify and share the patterns among better practices to connect the dots of Product Strategy, Product OKRs, and Product Discovery.

Here are a few ways we can work together:

Learn through my free, in-depth Product Strategy, Product OKRs, or Product Discovery content libraries.

Hire me to work with you or your team(s) 1:1 in workshops or coaching.

Product Practice Newsletter

1 tip & 3 resources per week to improve your Strategy, OKRs, and Discovery practices in less than 5 minutes.

Read more from Product Practice Newsletter

Product Practice #328 My 2024 Mid-Year Review READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Jun 28, 2024 READING TIME 5 min & 20 sec This is the last newsletter before my annual summer writing break. I will return on August 16th after next week's issue. In the meantime, follow me on LinkedIn for more hands-on content. ☀️ Dear Reader, I first encountered the concept of a mid-year review via Tiago Forte a few years back. After I published 7 Things I Learned from Writing a Weekly Product Management Newsletter for...

Product Practice #327 How Product Leaders CanGuide Their Team's OKRs READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Jun 21, 2024 READING TIME 3 min & 51 sec This is the second-to-last newsletter before my annual summer writing break. I will return on August 16th after next week's issue. ☀️ For the scope of this essay, I will define Product Leaders as members of a Product Management function with people management responsibilities (e.g., Director of Product, Head of Product, VP of Product, etc.). Product leaders...

Product Practice #326 4 Learnings fromWorking on 40 NSMs READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Jun 14, 2024 READING TIME 5 min & 0 sec Dear Reader, During an ongoing long-term Discovery and Metrics Coaching engagement, I had the opportunity to meet many different external and internal-facing teams. One of this company’s focus points is the establishment of more metrics-informed decision-making, and they landed on North Star Metrics (NSMs) as a critical vehicle for that. Here are my four key takeaways...