🛠️ The Consequences of Strategy Choices

The Consequences
of Strategy Choices




Dec 1, 2023


3 min & 41 sec

​Dear Reader,​

As mentioned last week, I’m a big fan of using flexible structures to define Product Strategy. One of the core ideas is the modular relationship between:

(I recently heard about Rob Hayes's talk on “Atomic Strategy” - Kudos to him for giving that structure a memorable name).

Since nobody can predict the success of a Strategy upfront anyway, there are only two practices worth focusing on instead:

Use the “right” Strategy Components to describe the Patterns in your context.

Depending on the type of your company culture, product maturity, and business model, some components are more useful than others.

Maybe you work in a smaller company where your Company Vision is already very product-centered–and you don’t need to go through the tick-box exercise of having another Product Vision.

Or your product’s distribution is pre-defined by the company’s focus on being sales-led.

Or the b2c nature of your product requires multiple user segments instead of differentiating between users, buyers, and champions in b2b Product Strategy.

Creating coherence between components by understanding the consequences of choice.

You can easily reduce the effectiveness of one Strategy Component by almost sabotaging it through another component’s choice (no matter the Strategy Pattern).

Let’s say you’re a company with a strong offline retail presence, and you choose a notoriously offline user segment for your strategy. In addition, you choose to serve the job of “Feel Safe about non-money Asset Value” for them through the value proposition of a “Watch Collection Evaluation.”

But then you prioritize social media and YouTube Ads for the distribution of your value proposition. You render the previous strategy choices ineffective compared to picking a distribution channel that matches your audience choices.

Instead, you should focus on a distribution channel that leverages the existing strengths AND aligns with the chosen audiences, like an In-Store Sales-assisted Evaluation.


  • Check the components of your current strategy articulation for gaps and unnecessary fluff: What choices are the result of the template/framework you used, and what choices might be missing to improve the usefulness of your strategy?
  • Consider Brian Balfour’s Four Fits concept to check the coherence (or fit) among your Product Strategy choices.
  • Test your strategy by playing it back to close team members first to receive feedback on what might be missing to form coherence.

Thank you for Practicing Product,


PS.: If you like this newsletter, you'll also love Ant Murphy's writings on Product Management:

Image for The PBL Newsletter - by Ant Murphy

The PBL Newsletter - by Ant Murphy

Helping Founders and Product People grow their Business and Craft

Subscribe for regular posts on Product Management, Business and Leadership.

Content I found Practical This Week

How Linear Builds Product

Once we have the strategy in mind, we then define a high-level roadmap for the next half of the year based on that. The strategy, for example, might be “focusing on large company needs.” We don’t have complicated ways to rank or vote on projects. Instead, we believe that if the leadership team and the whole company spend time with customers and use the product regularly, the needs and opportunities become more apparent. Then it’s just a matter of sequencing and scoping.

Understanding Michael Porter, by Joan Magretta

Avoid striving to be the best, which pits you against others in a zero-sum battle for the same customers and profits. This is a mistake, encouraged by vivid metaphors from war and sports. Competing to be the best leads to a) convergence on the same commodified offerings; eroded profits due to continuous one-upmanship; reduced choice for customers; and stifled innovation. Better metaphor: competing on unique value is like the performing arts; there are many good singers and actors, each distinctive, and they have their own audience.

What the heck is strategy work?

Because the framework role is charged with creating conditions for a shared mental model space across the leadership team, it is naturally conservative. When wearing this hat, I want to ensure that there is a stable foundation of framings and lenses, neatly polished, accessible to all, easy to grasp, like tools in a toolbox. The silly sensing role keeps constantly messing with this toolbox, questioning whether the screwdriver is actually a butterfly … and what if this wasn’t a toolbox, but rather … oh, I don’t know, a sunset?

What did you think of this week's newsletter?







That's all, Reader. If you enjoyed today's issue, please do reply (it helps with deliverability). If you didn't, you can unsubscribe here.

Who is Tim Herbig?

As a Product Management Coach, I guide Product Teams to measure the progress of their evidence-informed decisions.

I identify and share the patterns among better practices to connect the dots of Product Strategy, Product OKRs, and Product Discovery.

Here are a few ways we can work together:

Learn through my free, in-depth Product Strategy, Product OKRs, or Product Discovery content libraries.

Hire me to work with you or your team(s) 1:1 in workshops or coaching.

Product Practice Newsletter

1 tip & 3 resources per week to improve your Strategy, OKRs, and Discovery practices in less than 5 minutes.

Read more from Product Practice Newsletter

Product Practice #328 My 2024 Mid-Year Review READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Jun 28, 2024 READING TIME 5 min & 20 sec This is the last newsletter before my annual summer writing break. I will return on August 16th after next week's issue. In the meantime, follow me on LinkedIn for more hands-on content. ☀️ Dear Reader, I first encountered the concept of a mid-year review via Tiago Forte a few years back. After I published 7 Things I Learned from Writing a Weekly Product Management Newsletter for...

Product Practice #327 How Product Leaders CanGuide Their Team's OKRs READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Jun 21, 2024 READING TIME 3 min & 51 sec This is the second-to-last newsletter before my annual summer writing break. I will return on August 16th after next week's issue. ☀️ For the scope of this essay, I will define Product Leaders as members of a Product Management function with people management responsibilities (e.g., Director of Product, Head of Product, VP of Product, etc.). Product leaders...

Product Practice #326 4 Learnings fromWorking on 40 NSMs READ ON HERBIG.CO PUBLISHED Jun 14, 2024 READING TIME 5 min & 0 sec Dear Reader, During an ongoing long-term Discovery and Metrics Coaching engagement, I had the opportunity to meet many different external and internal-facing teams. One of this company’s focus points is the establishment of more metrics-informed decision-making, and they landed on North Star Metrics (NSMs) as a critical vehicle for that. Here are my four key takeaways...