🛠️ PP #297: Treat your Product Strategy like a Product


Treat your Product Strategy
like a Product

READ ON

​HERBIG.CO​

PUBLISHED

Oct 13, 2023

READING TIME

4 min & 38 sec

Before we get started: My channel of choice for contributing to supporting those in Israel that are in need. More options can be found here.

​Dear Reader,​

It’s easy to lose track of the actual purpose of strategy work, especially between the noise of Product Strategy frameworks and how a “good” strategy should look according to Twitter or LinkedIn. Product Teams should work forward from the value for the recipient, not backward from the defaults of others.

Instead of treating practices like Product Strategy as a tick-box exercise, treat it like a product: Understand for whom you’re trying to create what value and design your process and output accordingly, with early validation in mind.

Start with your Audience. Product Strategy should lead to work that produces “outward-facing” products, but it’s supposed to be consumed by internal audiences. Typically, that’s a) stakeholders and leadership, b) other departments, and c) the members of your product team.

What’s the job of your Strategy work? The Strategy aims to serve a different job for each of these audiences. For leadership it’s about being able to trust the direction and decisions of the team and horizontal and vertical coherence within the company. For your team, however, it’s about having clear, reliable, yet flexible decision-making guardrails for prioritization.

How to distribute Strategy? Again, this will depend on the audience. A one-pager or concise .ppt might best match their consumption patterns for leadership. Translating your choices into an agreed canvas-like structure between departments helps the information flow. And within your team, you need to find a shape that’s easy to comprehend, with optional deep dives to back up your choices and translate them into goals to measure your progress.

How to derisk Strategy Creation? Test the assumptions about your strategy as soon as you realize they are only assumptions. One assumption might be the coherence with the company's direction. This might require periodic strategy check-ins with leadership. Another assumption could be the coherence and comprehensibility of your efforts. Sharing synthesized strategy statements and conclusions with your team on an ongoing basis helps to mitigate the “big bang confusion” or “grand reveal rejection.”

There are more questions to consider when creating your Product Strategy to succeed in your target market. However, acknowledging these overlaps can help you go from filling out a template to creating a valuable artifact.

HOW TO PUT THIS THEORY INTO PRACTICE

  • Ask the recipients of your Product Strategy what they need to get out of this artifact. What should “it” help them do (differently)? Design your process accordingly.
  • When did you share your current thinking outside your “usual” collaborators? Seek internal exposure to test your assumptions of comprehensibility and value.
  • Iterate your strategy structure and format based on internal usefulness, not someone else’s template instructions.​

That's (almost) all, Reader. If you enjoyed today's issue, please do reply (it helps with deliverability). If you didn't, you can unsubscribe here.

Thank you for Practicing Product,

Tim

Need to practice strategy hands-on?

My self-paced Path to Product Strategy Course enables you to form, execute, and measure the progress of coherent Product Strategy Choices based on structure and evidence.

What did you think of this week's newsletter?

​👎​

​Bad​

​🤷‍♂️​

​Meh​

​👍​

​Great​

​Click here if you only want to see what's behind each option​

Content I found Practical This Week

Who Should Do Strategy?

The tricky thing is that strategy is an integrative discipline. It is inherently horizontal not vertical. It is just like general management in this respect. The core task of general management is to integrate across the functions to make sound decisions. And so is the core task of strategy. To be fair, it is not as though the rest of the functions aren’t integrative at all. For example, finance needs to take an integrative view across the company. But it doesn’t have the responsibility for figuring out what all the other functions should do.

10 Product Strategy Mistakes to Avoid

If you find yourself struggling to come up with an effective strategy for an entire product, then this may be an indication that the product has grown too big and has become too heterogeneous. Instead of introducing feature-based strategies, consider unbundling one or more capabilities and creating product variants.

What makes a strategy great

You can debate the form a strategy should take, whether a four-sentence “master plan” or a few dozen bullets or a six-pager or an eighty-pager or a template like Salesforce’s V2MOM or a Notion template you found on the Internet or answering three questions from a Twitter pundit or some sort of “Canvas.” Regardless, its job is to communicate “how we will win.” There are a lot of documents titled “Strategy,” but very little great strategy. The formula for great strategy isn’t decided by the format of the output document.

Who is Tim Herbig?

As a Product Management Coach, I guide Product Teams to measure the progress of their evidence-informed decisions.

I identify and share the patterns among better practices to connect the dots of Product Strategy, Product OKRs, and Product Discovery.

Here are a few ways we can work together:

Product Practice Newsletter

1 tip & 3 resources per week to improve your Strategy, OKRs, and Discovery practices in less than 5 minutes. Explore my new book on realprogressbook.com

Read more from Product Practice Newsletter

Product Practice #407 Your Goal Depends on Another Team — Now What? PUBLISHED May 7, 2026 READ ON HERBIG.CO Dear Reader, Your Key Result says to "Improve Conversion Rate by 7%," but you only control on-site search. You want to drive customer retention, but the marketing team is focused on new acquisition. Most teams respond in one of two ways: they water down the goal until it fits their scope (and lose the ambition), or they keep the big goal and quietly accept they can't move it. Both lead...

Product Practice #406 Why your Company's POV on OKRs matters more than Processes PUBLISHED Apr 30, 2026 READ ON HERBIG.CO Dear Reader, Before I talk with companies about OKR cadences, templates, or tools, I ask them: "What do you expect to change by using OKRs?" The answers take a bit of time. Not because they don't exist, but because OKRs have been treated as a solution without a problem to solve. OKRs haven't been treated as a product, but as a process without purpose. They've chosen a...

Product Practice #405 How to treat Prototypes as Decision-Making Tools PUBLISHED Apr 23, 2026 READ ON HERBIG.CO From Strategy Choice to Planned Experiments in One Workshop In my upcoming live remote workshop From Strategy to Discovery, I take you from sharpening your Product Strategy, to defining leading indicators for measuring progress, all the way to prioritized assumptions you need to derisk end-to-end. Three 4h Live Sessions - Lifetime Material and Recording Access - Real Results Join...